Don’t lose perspective says Nicholas Kristof in the 10/31/10 issue of the New York Times. Until 2008 we had only No Child Left Behind aka NCLB (the current name for the Elementary and Secondary School Act) which has been roundly criticized in education circles in spite of the initial bipartisan send off as the new century began.
By now, in California and other states minority groups form the majority. See the San Francisco Chronicle November 17, 2010, “When minorities are the majority” by Arun Ramanathan. You didn’t see this happening? Our education for those students is no longer the old style sit-in-your-seat-and-drink-it-in model.
middle school renovated after a bond passed
It isn’t even the model that mostly white student schools use nowadays, especially when students reach middle school and begin to lag behind, if they haven’t already. For anyone, studies describe what works. For instance, Edsource‘s report “Gaining Ground in the Middle School: Why Some Schools Do Better.” You can leave it, but if you’re looking to change, you’d be wise to take it.
The latest anxiety is teacher education, never mind that educators have been hollering about it since the 1983 report Nation At Risk. Give us a break–it’s a favorite worry of those who like to blame all on weak teachers. If only teacher’s unions would let the experts get rid of “bad” teachers. If only teacher training was upgraded.
The United States does need to look at what other nations do to find good teachers, accepting high quality scholars would help. Raising salaries would help. Training in critical thinking, problem solving, effective communication, and collaboration would help. All were points made by Thomas Friedman in his Sunday, November 21, 2010, New York Times column titled “Teaching For America.”
Does the world think teacher training-whether pre-service or staff development– isn’t happening? Does anyone think that various school boards haven’t analyzed the compensation issue, realizing that the old “steps” approach no longer works? Do teaching institutions not try to accept the best?
Here is what everyone doesn’t remember. In America individual states can listen to the federal government, but their decisions are made depending are where they are regionally and demographically in the country. No one can tell all states to change.
The federal Department of Education can offer grants like Race to the Top which have excellent guidelines. The president can be correct when he reminds the 300 million citizens of the U.S. that being well-educated is what makes a country strong. The governors of the 50 states can designate a commission to come up with Common Core Standards and ask, but not require, the states to teach them.
However, three main things must be done no matter where you live. State departments of education, school boards, and teachers must address the accountability issue and the assessments used to evaluate accountability.
They must address the gap in achievement for the minorities that are now the majority of traditional public, many charter public, and even parochial schools in this diverse country. Every week another model is given accolades.
Last, state departments of education, school boards, and teachers must find a way out of the financial mess. Whether it’s through changes in the pension system, a different road for compensation, changes in the structure of a particular school district, or the realignment of school districts, anything can be tried. Keeping what is already there without paying is not an option.
The obstacle is to get states or regions in a state to agree on any of them.